Messages as evidence: what a document can and cannot do
ChatExhibits turns an export of your messages into a clear, dated, numbered document with a fingerprint of the file. Whether and how that document counts is decided by a court, under rules that differ from one country to the next. This page sets out what those rules say in the United States, France and Spain, each with its source, and what the document does not replace. It is not legal advice.
By Martin Ferret · Published · Last updated
What the document is, and what it is not
It presents an export faithfully: every message, its sender and time, numbered pages, the photos as figures, and a certificate with the SHA-256 fingerprint of the file you gave. Anyone holding that file can check the fingerprint.
It does not show that the export is complete or that nothing was deleted before it was made, and it is not a certification by a qualified person, a sworn record by an officer of the court, or a qualified electronic trust service.
United States
Federal Rule of Evidence 901 asks the person offering an item to produce evidence sufficient to support a finding that the item is what they claim it is, for example the testimony of a witness with knowledge or the item’s distinctive characteristics. States have their own equivalents.
The court decides whether evidence is admissible.
Some courts publish practical guidance for people representing themselves. A California court, for example, asks for text messages to be printed out, because it will not look at a phone, and for copies for the other party.
France
In civil matters, facts can be proven by any means unless the law says otherwise, and the official justice portal names SMS, emails and screenshots among them. Evidence must be gathered fairly.
The Cour de cassation has held that the author of text messages cannot ignore that they are recorded by the receiving phone, so the recipient may use them.
A constat drawn up by a commissaire de justice remains the reference for establishing the content of messages: outside criminal matters, its findings are taken as true until proven otherwise. It is a paid service. ChatExhibits does not replace it; it organises and presents the exchanges.
A constat is what people turn to when the other side may dispute that the messages are real, or when they could disappear; the official page on online harassment mentions it for that purpose.
Spain
The Civil Procedure Act admits means that store words, data and figures, and private documents have full value when their authenticity is not challenged.
When the authenticity of messages is challenged, the Supreme Court has held that the burden falls on the party presenting them, and an expert report may be needed.
A notarial act of presence records what a notary perceives, such as the messages shown on a phone.
Your own conversations, and other people’s data
Use the tool for conversations you took part in. Opening or using someone else’s correspondence can be an offence in France, accessing stored communications without authorisation is an offence under US federal law, and in Spain the secrecy of communications does not apply against someone who took part in the conversation.
Evidence obtained unfairly can be set aside. In France, a court weighs whether it is indispensable and proportionate; in a divorce, evidence obtained by violence or fraud is excluded.
The other participants have rights over their personal data. The GDPR does not apply to purely personal use, and processing needed to establish or defend legal claims may be allowed; share the document only with those who need it.
Common questions
Does a ChatExhibits PDF replace a commissaire de justice or a notary?
No. A constat or a notarial act is drawn up by a public officer and has a legal value of its own. ChatExhibits presents an export clearly and lets anyone check its fingerprint; it does not replace either.
Will the court accept my messages?
Nobody can promise that here. The court decides whether and how evidence is admitted, and the rules differ by country and by case. A lawyer, or a court’s self-help service, can tell you what applies to you.
What does the SHA-256 fingerprint prove?
That the file has not changed since the document was made: anyone who computes the fingerprint of the same file gets the same value. It says nothing about what happened before the export.
Can I use screenshots instead?
Courts and official pages mention screenshots among possible evidence. A document made from the export carries every message with its exact time and a fingerprint of the file, which screenshots do not.
Can I include messages I was not part of?
The tool is meant for your own conversations. Using other people’s private correspondence can be an offence and can make evidence unusable.
Is this legal advice?
No. This page reports what official texts and pages say, with their dates. It does not say what to do in your situation.
Keep reading
- Export a WhatsApp Chat on iPhone or AndroidStep-by-step export instructions for iPhone and Android, what “Attach Media” changes, what WhatsApp Desktop can export, and what ends up inside the ZIP.
- WhatsApp Export Format: the TXT and ZIPWhat is inside a WhatsApp export: the two timestamp formats, the invisible direction marks, attachment lines on iOS and Android, and how media is named.
- What Is Bates Numbering? Format, ContinuityWhere the name comes from, what a Bates number looks like, why it runs continuously across a production, and what stamping one does not accomplish.
- SHA-256 File Integrity: Is a File Unchanged?What a hash is, why changing one byte changes the whole digest, how to compute one on macOS, Windows and Linux, and what a digest cannot tell you.
- WhatsApp Chat to PDF for CourtTurn a WhatsApp export into a dated, page-numbered PDF with a SHA-256 certificate, read in your browser. Made for people who need to show what was said.
- Android SMS to PDF as EvidencePrint Android text messages from an SMS Backup & Restore file as a dated, numbered PDF with photos and a certificate. Nothing is uploaded.
- Messenger Messages as Evidence, in a PDFTurn the Messenger conversation in your Facebook data download into a dated, numbered PDF with photos, reactions and a SHA-256 certificate.
- Instagram Messages as Evidence, in a PDFPrint an Instagram direct message conversation from your data download as a dated, numbered PDF with its photos and a certificate, in your browser.
- Telegram Chat to PDF for CourtTurn a Telegram Desktop export, JSON or HTML, into a dated, page-numbered PDF with photos, voice messages and a SHA-256 certificate.
- Export iMessage to PDF for CourtTurn iMessage and iPhone SMS from a Mac or an unencrypted iPhone backup into a dated, numbered PDF with a certificate, read in your browser.
- How to Export Android Text MessagesExport Android SMS and MMS to a file with SMS Backup & Restore or SMS Import / Export, step by step, then copy it to your computer.
- How to Download Your Messenger MessagesDownload your Messenger conversations with Export your information, in JSON, plus the backup of end-to-end encrypted chats, step by step.
- How to Download Your Instagram MessagesDownload your Instagram direct messages with Export your information, in JSON, step by step, with how long it takes and what is left out.
- How to Export a Telegram ChatExport a Telegram chat or all your data from Telegram Desktop, in machine-readable JSON, step by step. The phone apps have no export.
- How to Export iMessages and iPhone SMSGet your iMessages and iPhone texts as a file: chat.db on a Mac, an unencrypted iPhone backup, or an iMazing CSV, step by step.